Retirement Income Strategies Compared: How to Choose the Approach That Fits Your Household

Retirement Income Strategies Compared: How to Choose the Approach That Fits Your Household

|

Key Takeaways:

  • No single retirement income strategy fits every household. Each one handles market risk differently, and each costs you something in return, whether that’s simplicity, flexibility or spending certainty.
  • How much of your spending is already guaranteed shapes which strategy fits. When Social Security and other guaranteed income cover your essentials, your portfolio has more room to move. When they don’t, a visible cash reserve or firm spending limits may matter more.
  • Strategies can be combined. One household might cover essentials with guaranteed income, hold two years of withdrawals in cash, and let lifestyle spending adjust within set limits.

No retirement income strategy fits every household. Each common retirement income strategy handles a falling market in its own way, and each asks you to give something up in return.

If you’re in the Charlotte area and retired or within a few years of it, with most of your savings in a 401(k), IRA or employer plan, the saving part is largely done. What’s left is deciding how to draw on it. This comparison puts five approaches side by side and runs the same couple through each one.

Strategy Versus Plan: What Each One Decides

A retirement income strategy decides where each month’s money comes from and what you do when markets fall. A plan covers everything around it, like how much you need, which accounts to draw from for tax reasons, and when to start Social Security. The comparison here is about the strategy.

Take Mike and Molly (hypothetical, for illustration only, with round numbers that ignore growth, taxes, and inflation). They spend $7,000 a month, $4,500 on essentials and $2,500 on lifestyle. Social Security and other guaranteed income total $4,500, so their $1,000,000 portfolio must cover a $2,500 monthly gap, or $30,000 a year.

To find your own gap, start with our guide to retirement income planning.

Five Retirement Income Strategies Side by Side

Five common retirement income strategies differ mainly in where the monthly money comes from and what happens in a down year. Each is a general approach, not a product. Each one below covers what the strategy handles well, what it costs you, and who it tends to fit, using Mike and Molly’s same numbers.

Income-Centric: Spend What the Portfolio Pays

An income-centric strategy pays you from the interest and dividends your investments produce and leaves the principal alone. You rarely need to sell, and the idea is easy to follow. The cost is that your paycheck rises and falls with interest rates and payouts you don’t control.

The portfolio can also end up built around yield instead of the mix that suits the household. A company can cut its dividend, and bond income drops when rates fall.

It tends to fit households whose gap is small compared with what their investments already pay. For Mike and Molly, the paycheck depends on whether interest and dividends cover $30,000 a year. If they fall short, they hold more income-oriented investments or spend less.

Total Return: Draw From the Whole Portfolio

A total return strategy treats your savings as one portfolio with one withdrawal rule. Rebalancing, which means selling what has grown past its target share and buying what has fallen behind, decides what to sell. It’s simple to set up and works across account types. The cost is that in a down market you may be selling at lower prices.

The rule also takes discipline. You must follow it when the headlines are loud. How much to take is its own question, covered in What’s a Safe Withdrawal Rate in Today’s Market?

It tends to fit households who are comfortable with one portfolio and a set rule. Mike and Molly move $2,500 a month from one portfolio and sell whatever rebalancing says to sell.

Bucket: Match Money to When You Need It

A bucket strategy splits savings by when you’ll spend them. The next year or two of withdrawals sits in cash, and money for later sits in progressively longer-term investments. A visible cash reserve can make a downturn easier to sit through. The cost is higher, and cash may earn less than invested money.

The ongoing work is refilling the cash, which means deciding when to sell from the other buckets to top it up. Our article on why bad markets early in retirement do outsized damage explains the risk the cash is there for.

It tends to fit households who’d be tempted to sell in a panic. Mike and Molly set aside $60,000 of their portfolio, two years of their gap, in cash and refill it when markets allow.

Income Floor: Cover Essentials With Guaranteed Income

An income floor strategy uses guaranteed income, like Social Security, a pension or an annuity, to cover essential spending. The portfolio pays only for the rest, so essential bills come from income that doesn’t rise or fall with your portfolio. The cost is that the floor only reaches as far as your guaranteed income does.

Waiting past full retirement age raises your Social Security benefit until age 70, which is the idea behind the Social Security bridge strategy.1 If you fill the floor with an annuity, you give up some flexibility and access to that money. See annuities for income, pros and cons for Charlotte retirees.

“Guaranteed” describes who owes the payment, not what it will buy. A pension depends on the plan behind it, an annuity on the insurer’s ability to pay, and a fixed payment can lose ground as costs rise.

It tends to fit households whose guaranteed income already comes close to covering essentials. Mike and Molly’s $4,500 of guaranteed income covers their $4,500 of essentials. A down year is more likely to change their trips and dining than their groceries.

Guardrails: Let Spending Adjust Within Set Limits

A guardrails strategy starts with a withdrawal amount and sets upper and lower limits in advance. If the portfolio rises past one limit, you give yourself a raise. If it falls past the other, you trim. You trade in-the-moment decisions for clear rules. The cost is that your income can change from year to year.

It tends to fit households with lifestyle spending they could cut back for a while. Mike and Molly start at $30,000 a year and agree in advance to trim their withdrawal by, for example, 10% if the portfolio falls past a set level. That’s an illustrative rule, not a recommendation.

How the Five Strategies Compare

StrategyWhat it handlesWhat it asks of youWhere it tends to fit
Income-centricLittle selling, easy to followIncome that moves with rates and payoutsA small gap compared with what investments pay
Total returnOne portfolio, works across accountsFollowing the rule, even when selling in a down marketHouseholds comfortable with a set rule
BucketA visible cash reserve for down marketsManaging and refilling the bucketsHouseholds tempted to sell in a panic
Income floorEssentials that don’t depend on marketsEnough guaranteed income, or an annuity’s tradeoffsHouseholds whose essentials are close to covered
GuardrailsClear rules for raises and trimsIncome that changes from year to yearHouseholds with lifestyle spending they can trim

Each strategy answers the same question, what happens in a down market, in a different way. In my experience, the strategy that does its job is the one you can stick with in a bad year.

How to Choose Between Retirement Income Strategies

The choice usually comes down to how much of your spending is already guaranteed, how much you could trim in a bad year and what you’d do when markets fall. Your account mix matters too. A household with most essentials covered has more options than one leaning on the portfolio for groceries.

Four questions do most of the work of sorting which strategy fits your household:

  • How much of your essential spending is covered by income that doesn’t depend on markets?
  • How much of your spending could you trim in a down year without hardship?
  • Would a visible cash reserve keep you from selling in a panic?
  • How is your money split among pre-tax, Roth, and taxable accounts?

Account mix matters because each strategy draws from accounts that are taxed differently, which How to Turn Your 401(k) Into a Paycheck walks through. For the tax side, see how North Carolina taxes retirement income and RMD timing and tax tips.

Some people would rather pick whichever strategy has the strongest track record. These are tools for different jobs, so there’s no single scoreboard to compare them on. None of them removes market risk. Each one decides where that risk shows up: in your spending, your cash or your portfolio.

If you’re retiring in 1 to 5 years, these questions are worth answering before your first withdrawal.

Why Households Often Combine More Than One Strategy

Because each strategy handles a different risk, you can layer them. Guaranteed income can cover essentials, a cash reserve can cover spending for a set stretch of a down market, and spending limits can keep withdrawals in check. A combination takes more to set up, but it can address more than one worry at once.

Mike and Molly’s combined version looks like this. Their guaranteed income covers essentials; $60,000 of their portfolio, two years of their gap, sits in cash; and their $2,500 a month of lifestyle spending adjusts within set limits.

The tradeoff is more moving parts to review each year. For more on putting the pieces together, see how to create reliable retirement income in your 60s. Comparing strategies against a household’s own numbers is the core of our retirement income services.

How Employer Benefits Can Shift Which Strategy Fits

If part of your income arrives on a fixed schedule, such as deferred compensation installments, it may act as an income floor for those years. If most of your savings sit in one employer plan, the strategy you choose and your account decisions affect each other.

For Wells Fargo employees with deferred compensation, payments generally follow the elections made when the pay was deferred, and they’re taxed as ordinary income. If you elected installments, that income ends when they do. Unlike a 401(k), deferred compensation is generally an unsecured promise, so payments depend on the employer’s ability to pay.

Review your plan documents and distribution elections before you settle on a strategy. Our article on what Wells Fargo employees should know about deferred compensation covers the options, and our Wells Fargo employees page has more.

Retirement Income Strategies FAQs

1. Which Retirement Income Strategy Is Right for My Household?

It depends on how much of your spending is guaranteed, how much you could trim and how you’d react in a down market. The four questions in the fit test above cover a lot of it. Some households combine pieces of more than one strategy.

2. What Is the Difference Between a Retirement Income Strategy and a Retirement Income Plan?

A strategy is the method for drawing money each month. A plan coordinates that method with your spending, taxes and Social Security timing. The plan tells you which strategy fits, and the strategy is how the plan runs month to month.

3. How Is a Bucket Strategy Different From a Total Return Approach?

A bucket strategy holds the next year or two of spending in cash, so that money isn’t in the market when it falls. The rest stays invested, and the cash may earn less. A total return approach keeps one portfolio and sells what rebalancing says to sell, whatever the market is doing. The bucket asks more management, and total return asks more discipline in a bad year. Which one fits depends on how you’d react to a downturn.

4. Do I Need an Annuity to Use an Income Floor Strategy?

No. Social Security and a pension count as guaranteed income. An annuity is one optional way to raise the floor, with its own tradeoffs covered in annuities for income.

Compare Retirement Income Strategies Against Your Own Numbers

At Calamita Wealth Management, we help Charlotte-area retirees and Wells Fargo employees test these approaches against their own spending, accounts and taxes. Then we coordinate income, taxes and investments so the strategy and the plan work together.

If you’d like to see which approach fits your household, we’d be glad to talk it through. Schedule a time to talk with our team.

Resources:

  1. Social Security Administration, Delayed Retirement Credits: https://www.ssa.gov/benefits/retirement/planner/delayret.html

This article is for educational purposes only and isn’t individualized tax, legal or investment advice. Calamita Wealth Management is a fee-only registered investment adviser. Talk with a qualified professional about your situation before acting.

Todd Calamita, CFP® Avatar

Founder & President, CFP®